Max
09-08-2002, 12:34 PM
Stroke care 'still not good enough'
Specialist care is the best option
People are dying unnecessarily and living with long term disability because of a lack of dedicated stroke units, according to a survey by the Royal College of Physicians.
130,000 people have strokes every year and their chances of recovery depend on being treated in specialist units
The report says that while there has been a slight improvement over the past four years many hospitals will not meet the government's target for better treatment.
The College reckons that on current figures, it will be 73 years before all stroke patients spend half their time in hospital in specialist units.
Click here to watch our interview with Margaret Goose.
Breakfast talked to Margaret Goose, the Chief Executive of the Stroke Association. She said:
"We are urging all medical staff in casualty to be better trained in this area."
Three quarters of stroke patients admitted into hospital are not receiving special care. They need to be in a specialist stoke unit where they are getting the right aftercare. Every five seconds someone somewhere is having a stroke. Every 1 in 10 stokes is being experienced by the under 25s, and it is the biggest killer, and the biggest cause of disability. We want better care and more stroke units. We are urging for all staff to be specifically trained especially in casualty and A&E where misdiagnoses have been known to take place.
Click here to watch our interview with Ron Carter
Breakfast spoke to Ron Carter, a stroke patient. He Said:
"It's very frightening."
I was watching TV stood up and fell flat on my face, my wife took me to the doctors and I was told not to worry, but things got progressively worse and my left side became totally paralysed, my leg felt like a lump of lead and I couldn't do anything. I knew there were warning signs of a stroke but doctors need to be trained to recognise them. I've now got back 65% use of my left arm but it is very frightening
Stroke is one of the UK's biggest killers and the single main cause of severe disability. Each year 130,000 people have a stroke.
The survey found that lack of resources were to blame for problems with facilities, diagnosis, treatment and care.
People are dying unnecessarily and living with long-term disability
Dr Tony Rudd
It also found 27% of stroke patients spent most of their stay in a stroke unit compared to 25% in 1999 - that is an increase of 1% per year.
If that continues, it will be 73 years before all patients with a stroke spend half their hospital time in a dedicated stroke unit.
The survey also showed that only 36% of stroke patients spent any time at all in a stroke unit despite evidence that patients fare better in specialist facilities.
Physical assessments
Only 64% of patients were recorded as having a swallowing assessment, only 63% a visual fields assessment, and only 49% being weighed.
Without this information, the patient is unlikely to be offered appropriate therapy, such as speech or language therapy or physiotherapy.
This may lead to future problems in regaining the use of their limbs, sight, hearing and ability to eat properly.
Other findings include:
The number of hospitals who treat stroke patients in a stroke unit has increased from 45% in 1998 and 56% in 1999 to 73% in 2001/2, but the number of allocated beds remains inadequate and cannot meet the demand
Nearly one in five patients are not getting a brain scan
One in ten patients who should be prescribed aspirin or similar drugs following their stay in hospital is not receiving them
The number of Trusts who have a consultant with responsibility for stroke has gone up to 80%, but the majority of doctors doing this only spend about eight hours of their week in this role.
The British Association of Stroke Physicians estimates an average district should have two full-time stroke physicians.
Dr Tony Rudd, a stroke specialist at Guy's and St Thomas' Hospital in London, said evidence suggested that 19% fewer people would die and 29% fewer would end up dead or disabled if they were treated in a specialist stroke unit.
That amounted to about 18,000 more people dying, or a total of 27,000 left dead or disabled, every year in the UK.
He said: "People are dying unnecessarily and living with long-term disability, some of which could have been avoided, because of the failure to deliver specialist stroke care.
Stroke care is moving forward but at a snail's pace
Margaret Goose
"Co-ordinated care saves lives and reduces disability.
"Although we are seeing improvements in stroke care, we are not going to achieve the ideal until stroke care is given a higher priority. We need more resources, staff, money and support to deliver effective stroke care."
More needed
Margaret Goose, chief executive of the Stroke Association, said she was "really disappointed" that nearly three quarters of stroke patients were not getting care in specialist stroke units.
She said: "Stroke care is moving forward but at a snail's pace.
"And while the improvement in care edges forward people are dying when they should not be or suffering from disability when they could be living independent lives."
The government's national service framework for older people stated that everyone who had a stroke should receive specialist care by 2004.
The audit covered England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
Home
When we are on air
Recent forums
Programme archive
Studio tour
Today's information
MEET THE TEAM
Presenters
Reporters
YOUR SAY
Contact us
Your comments
See also:
18 May 01 | Health
Stroke research warning
07 Feb 01 | Health
Stroke test 'could save lives'
02 Jun 00 | Health
Hospital 'worst place for a stroke'
Internet links:
Stroke Association
Department of Health
British Association of Stroke Physicians
Royal College of Physicians
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Top Breakfast stories now:
September 11: victim 0001
British firefighters honour New York colleagues
Near death experiences
Goodbye again
The Third Degree
Britain will pay blood price
Schools warned over cost of uniforms
The legacy of Flight 93
Links to more Breakfast stories are at the foot of the page.
E-mail this story to a friend
Links to more Breakfast stories
==============================
"Experience teaches that, of all the emotions, fear stands alone in its power to move us, or to capture us in its grip forever. In a world of terrors, there is nothing more fearsome that the unknown...especially when what is unknown is ourselves." Outer Limits(Fear Itself)
Specialist care is the best option
People are dying unnecessarily and living with long term disability because of a lack of dedicated stroke units, according to a survey by the Royal College of Physicians.
130,000 people have strokes every year and their chances of recovery depend on being treated in specialist units
The report says that while there has been a slight improvement over the past four years many hospitals will not meet the government's target for better treatment.
The College reckons that on current figures, it will be 73 years before all stroke patients spend half their time in hospital in specialist units.
Click here to watch our interview with Margaret Goose.
Breakfast talked to Margaret Goose, the Chief Executive of the Stroke Association. She said:
"We are urging all medical staff in casualty to be better trained in this area."
Three quarters of stroke patients admitted into hospital are not receiving special care. They need to be in a specialist stoke unit where they are getting the right aftercare. Every five seconds someone somewhere is having a stroke. Every 1 in 10 stokes is being experienced by the under 25s, and it is the biggest killer, and the biggest cause of disability. We want better care and more stroke units. We are urging for all staff to be specifically trained especially in casualty and A&E where misdiagnoses have been known to take place.
Click here to watch our interview with Ron Carter
Breakfast spoke to Ron Carter, a stroke patient. He Said:
"It's very frightening."
I was watching TV stood up and fell flat on my face, my wife took me to the doctors and I was told not to worry, but things got progressively worse and my left side became totally paralysed, my leg felt like a lump of lead and I couldn't do anything. I knew there were warning signs of a stroke but doctors need to be trained to recognise them. I've now got back 65% use of my left arm but it is very frightening
Stroke is one of the UK's biggest killers and the single main cause of severe disability. Each year 130,000 people have a stroke.
The survey found that lack of resources were to blame for problems with facilities, diagnosis, treatment and care.
People are dying unnecessarily and living with long-term disability
Dr Tony Rudd
It also found 27% of stroke patients spent most of their stay in a stroke unit compared to 25% in 1999 - that is an increase of 1% per year.
If that continues, it will be 73 years before all patients with a stroke spend half their hospital time in a dedicated stroke unit.
The survey also showed that only 36% of stroke patients spent any time at all in a stroke unit despite evidence that patients fare better in specialist facilities.
Physical assessments
Only 64% of patients were recorded as having a swallowing assessment, only 63% a visual fields assessment, and only 49% being weighed.
Without this information, the patient is unlikely to be offered appropriate therapy, such as speech or language therapy or physiotherapy.
This may lead to future problems in regaining the use of their limbs, sight, hearing and ability to eat properly.
Other findings include:
The number of hospitals who treat stroke patients in a stroke unit has increased from 45% in 1998 and 56% in 1999 to 73% in 2001/2, but the number of allocated beds remains inadequate and cannot meet the demand
Nearly one in five patients are not getting a brain scan
One in ten patients who should be prescribed aspirin or similar drugs following their stay in hospital is not receiving them
The number of Trusts who have a consultant with responsibility for stroke has gone up to 80%, but the majority of doctors doing this only spend about eight hours of their week in this role.
The British Association of Stroke Physicians estimates an average district should have two full-time stroke physicians.
Dr Tony Rudd, a stroke specialist at Guy's and St Thomas' Hospital in London, said evidence suggested that 19% fewer people would die and 29% fewer would end up dead or disabled if they were treated in a specialist stroke unit.
That amounted to about 18,000 more people dying, or a total of 27,000 left dead or disabled, every year in the UK.
He said: "People are dying unnecessarily and living with long-term disability, some of which could have been avoided, because of the failure to deliver specialist stroke care.
Stroke care is moving forward but at a snail's pace
Margaret Goose
"Co-ordinated care saves lives and reduces disability.
"Although we are seeing improvements in stroke care, we are not going to achieve the ideal until stroke care is given a higher priority. We need more resources, staff, money and support to deliver effective stroke care."
More needed
Margaret Goose, chief executive of the Stroke Association, said she was "really disappointed" that nearly three quarters of stroke patients were not getting care in specialist stroke units.
She said: "Stroke care is moving forward but at a snail's pace.
"And while the improvement in care edges forward people are dying when they should not be or suffering from disability when they could be living independent lives."
The government's national service framework for older people stated that everyone who had a stroke should receive specialist care by 2004.
The audit covered England, Wales and Northern Ireland.
Home
When we are on air
Recent forums
Programme archive
Studio tour
Today's information
MEET THE TEAM
Presenters
Reporters
YOUR SAY
Contact us
Your comments
See also:
18 May 01 | Health
Stroke research warning
07 Feb 01 | Health
Stroke test 'could save lives'
02 Jun 00 | Health
Hospital 'worst place for a stroke'
Internet links:
Stroke Association
Department of Health
British Association of Stroke Physicians
Royal College of Physicians
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites
Top Breakfast stories now:
September 11: victim 0001
British firefighters honour New York colleagues
Near death experiences
Goodbye again
The Third Degree
Britain will pay blood price
Schools warned over cost of uniforms
The legacy of Flight 93
Links to more Breakfast stories are at the foot of the page.
E-mail this story to a friend
Links to more Breakfast stories
==============================
"Experience teaches that, of all the emotions, fear stands alone in its power to move us, or to capture us in its grip forever. In a world of terrors, there is nothing more fearsome that the unknown...especially when what is unknown is ourselves." Outer Limits(Fear Itself)